The couple were pillars of their community. Bart had served as a Boy Scout den leader, while Krista took pride in being both a dedicated mother and the supportive “work-mother” to her colleagues. They owned a family cabin on White Lake’s Sawyer Lake Road, built by Bart’s father, where they spent weekends enjoying the tranquil 153-acre lake surrounded by dense woodland.

Their youngest son Chandler was their pride and joy. The parents frequently boasted to friends about his impressive achievements: graduating from Madison Area Technical College’s renewable resources engineering program, working at American Family Insurance, and most exciting of all, landing a coveted position at Elon Musk’s SpaceX in Florida. When Chandler wasn’t working, he spent time with his girlfriend Catheryn Mellender, whose family owned a farm in the Cottage Grove area.

But beneath this picture-perfect facade lay a web of deception that would ultimately lead to unthinkable tragedy.

On July 7, 2021, at 11:30AM, Chandler walked into the Northeast Precinct police station to file a missing person report. ¹ His parents, he explained, had left for their cabin on July 1st with another couple and had failed to return as planned. He showed officers a text message purportedly from his mother on July 4th: “Made it safely, cant get anything through, and yes, it’s packed. Going to white lake today for the parade and will be home on Monday night/Tuesday early. Love you lots!”

When investigators arrived at the family home on Oak Spring Circle, they found both of the Haldersons’ vehicles in the garage. Chandler explained that his parents had been picked up by friends he couldn’t identify. Inside the house, Deputy Seeley noticed sections of removed flooring and the outline of a half wall that was no longer there. In the basement, they observed a large piece of glass missing from the fireplace. Chandler claimed the dogs had broken it, cutting his toe and causing bleeding.

The cabin at White Lake told a different story. When investigators knocked on the door, no one answered. Peering through windows revealed that the cabin appeared unused for an extended period.

As the investigation deepened, inconsistencies in Chandler’s story emerged. ² Daniel Kroninger, Krista’s colleague, revealed that she had been scheduled to work on July 2nd but never showed up-unusual for someone so punctual. When Daniel visited the Halderson home that afternoon, he found both vehicles in the garage and a coffee table knocked over inside. After persistent knocking, Chandler appeared at a window and directed him to a side door, where he emerged soaking wet with a towel, claiming he’d just showered. A bandage covered his foot, which he said was injured when he broke the fireplace while playing with the dogs.

Neighbours found Chandler’s explanations increasingly implausible. When invited for dinner, he told them his parents had taken large amounts of money and alcohol to the cabin-completely out of character for the penny-pinching couple who rarely drank. The supposed mysterious friends who picked them up also struck neighbours as odd, since Bart and Krista always brought their own vehicle on trips for independence.

The breakthrough came when investigators spoke with Catheryn’s mother, Dulce Mellender. She described Chandler’s strange behaviour on July 5th when he arrived at their farm. He asked to swim in their pool but never actually got in the water. Dulce watched as he positioned his father’s car near their largest shed, then wandered the wood line in what she described as a daze.

Days later, Dulce noticed vultures circling the woodland area where she’d observed Chandler.

When investigators searched the Mellender property, Detective Brent Baverstock followed tire tracks from the shed into tall grass. Seventy-five yards into the woodland, he discovered a slight mound covered with foliage. Beneath it lay a horrific sight: a human torso covered in maggots, dressed in grey cargo pants with a black belt and nylon rope around the waist. Nearby lay a Target bag filled with bloody rags.

The medical examiner identified the remains as Bart Halderson. ³ Dr. Cori Ann Breslauer found multiple gunshot wounds, including an exit wound under the right ribcage, an abdominal wound that hit the spinal cord, and a gunshot to the neck. The injuries came from a rifle, and the death was ruled a homicide.

Additional evidence emerged from the property: scissors, a saw blade, and bolt cutters in a tank, with fatty tissue embedded on the saw blade’s sharp edge.

As Chandler was arrested on charges of providing false information, investigators uncovered the shocking truth: his entire life was a fabrication. ⁴ He wasn’t enrolled at Madison Area Technical College, didn’t work at American Family Insurance, and had no job offer from SpaceX. For years, he had created hundreds of fake emails from supposed college staff and insurance company representatives to maintain his elaborate deception.

In reality, Chandler was unemployed. While his parents believed he was working remotely in his bedroom, he spent his days playing video games. The net had begun closing in June 2021 when his suspicious parents started questioning his financial situation. His excuses about wage mix-ups and fabricated HR department emails were wearing thin.

The final straw came when Chandler claimed a concussion from falling down stairs would prevent him from taking the SpaceX position. Concerned, Bart contacted Madison Area Technical College directly to help with his son’s graduation documents-only to discover that Chandler had never been enrolled. ⁵

Following Chandler’s arrest, investigators found additional evidence. Cell phone data placed him in Sauk City on July 3rd, where a witness saw a man matching his description walking from the Wisconsin River area. Searching the wooded region near the river, investigators discovered more human remains: a severed leg, chunks of rotting flesh, a severed foot, and other body parts. DNA testing confirmed these belonged to Krista Halderson. ⁶

The investigation revealed the full scope of Chandler’s crimes. At the Halderson home, investigators found Bart and Krista’s cell phones and driver’s licenses hidden in shoes under a shelving unit, wrapped in paper towels and tin foil. Analysis showed that the text message from “Krista” reporting their safe arrival had been sent from the family home after both parents were dead.

Other evidence included: a bullet casing matching ammunition from a rifle gifted to Chandler by an online gaming friend; the rifle itself, hidden behind boards in Dulce’s shed; an axe covered in human blood; human skull fragments and over 200 bone fragments in the fireplace ashes; rope matching that found around Bart’s torso; and human blood in the freezer. ⁷

Chandler’s internet searches told their own story: “Body found Wisconsin,” “woman’s body found in Wisconsin,” “Wisconsin dismembered body found,” and searches for news about Bart and Krista. ⁸

Chandler’s trial began January 2, 2022. ^{9 10} Prosecutors argued that the murders occurred on July 1st after Bart discovered his son’s lies. They theorised Chandler shot his father, then ambushed Krista when she returned from work at 5PM. Surveillance showed Chandler leaving home just after 8PM to buy ice, presumably to preserve the bodies.

Over the next five days, prosecutors claimed, Chandler dismembered his parents’ bodies, burning some remains in the fireplace and disposing of others across Wisconsin. ^{11 12} The defence offered little resistance, with attorney Crystal Vera conceding guilt on most charges while questioning only the first-degree intentional homicide counts.

The jury deliberated just two hours before finding Chandler guilty on all counts: two counts of first-degree intentional homicide, mutilating corpses, hiding corpses, and falsifying information about missing persons. ¹³

At sentencing on March 16, 2022, Judge John Hyland handed down life imprisonment without the possibility of parole-only the third time in his career he’d imposed such a sentence. ¹⁴ “I cannot conceive of a way to fulfil my duty to the public I serve were I to perceive that at some point the individual who committed these crimes should be released back into that public,” he stated.

Assistant District Attorney Brown noted the tragic irony: “When faced with, in the grand scheme of things, a minor inconvenience in his life, Mr. Halderson chose to commit first-degree homicide two times.”

Even at sentencing, Chandler showed no remorse, speaking only to announce his intention to appeal.

Outside the courthouse, Dane County Sheriff Kalvin Barrett wore a yellow rose provided by the Halderson family-a representation of Bart and Krista’s missing souls. His words captured the tragedy’s scope: “The Halderson family lost three today: Bart and Krista in July of last year, and today Chandler.”

The case served as a chilling reminder of how a web of lies, when threatened with exposure, can drive someone to the most unthinkable acts. Chandler Halderson had grown up with every advantage, supported by loving parents who believed in his fabricated achievements. Rather than face the uncomfortable truth of his deception, he chose murder, dismemberment, and an elaborate cover-up that ultimately failed.

Bart and Krista Halderson, described by prosecutors as “normal folks just trying to live a normal life,” became victims of their son’s inability to confront reality. Their story serves as a tragic testament to how far some will go to avoid taking responsibility for their actions, and the devastating consequences when lies spiral beyond control.

On paper, the Halderson family seemed to have it all; a stable and loving marriage, a successful son that made them proud, and even a cabin for vacationing on the picturesque White Lake. In summer of 2021, however, cracks in the quintessential all-American family began to emerge, culminating with a very peculiar disappearance…

Sponsors:

Rocket Money: Thank you to Rocket Money for sponsoring this episode! It’s time to fight back against scammy subscriptions with Rocket Money. On average, people save $750. Save today at http://rocketmoney.com/morbidology

A Study of Strange: Thank you to A Study of Strange for sponsoring this episode! This show delves into some of the most peculiar stories, including true crime. Find A Study of Strange at https://astudyofstrange.com/ or wherever you get podcasts.

Exhibit C: Thank you to Exhibit C for sponsoring this episode! Wondery goes deeper into complex true crime stories to give you an inside look at the facts and now Wondery is launching the ultimate true crime fan destination. EXHIBIT C: https://wonderyexhibitc.com/

Audio Sources:

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 1 – Prosecution Opening Statement by William Brown”

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 4 – Defendant’s Police Interview Part 2”

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 1 – Mitchell Halderson – Defendant’s Brother”

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 3 – Cathryn Mellender – Defendant’s Ex-Girlfriend”

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 1-Sgt Justin Grones-Detective Langlade Co Shrffs Ofc”

“WI v. Chandler Halderson Trial Day 1 – Defense Opening Statement by Catherine Dorl”“

Sources:

Antigo Daily Journal, 7 July, 2021 – “Windsor Couple en Route to Langlade County Reported Missing”

DeForest Times-Tribune, 8 July, 2021 – “Dane County Authorities Need Help Searching for Missing Windsor Couple”

Antigo Daily Journal, 9 July, 2021 – “Dane County Sheriff Announces Developments in Case of Missing Windsor Couple”

The Daily Beast, 8 July, 2021 – “Son Arrested in Parents’ Suspicious Disappearance”

Associated Press, 15 July, 2021 – “Son Charged with Death of Father”

DeForst Times-Tribune, 25 August, 2021 – “Chandler Halderson Charged with Murder of Both Parents”

Associated Press, 1 September, 2021 – “Wisconsin Man Enters Not Guilty Plea”

The Chippewa Herald, 3 January, 2022 – “Accused of Killing and Dismembering his Parents”

Associated Press, 4 January, 2022 – “Trial Starts for Wisconsin Man Accused of Killing Parents”

DeForst Times-Tribune, 4 January, 2022 – “Halderson Trial Begins”

Antigo Daily Journal, 5 January, 2022 – “Brother, Officers Testify in Halderson Case”

The Chippewa Herald, 5 January, 2022 – “Caught in Web of Lies”

The Chippewa Herald, 7 January, 2022 – “Jurors in Chandler Halderson Murder Trial See Graphic Photos”

The Chippewa Herald, 7 January, 2022 – “Jury Sees Video of Police Interview”

DeForest Times-Tribune, 11 January, 2022 – “Halderson Trial Enters Second Week”

Kenosha News, 11 January, 2022 – “Jurors in Chandler Halderson Case See Rifle”

The Chippewa Herald, 19 January, 2022 – “Chandler Halderson’s Friends, Ex-Girlfriend, Testify”

Associated Press, 20 January, 2022 – “Wisconsin Man Convicted of killing, Dismembering his Parents”

The Chippewa Herald, 20 January, 2022 – “I’m Ready Whenever You Are”

The Chippewa Herald, 20 January, 2022 – “Chandler Halderson Found Guilty”

Baraboo News-Republic, 12 March, 2022 – “Man Wants to Skip his Sentencing”

Wisconsin State Journal, 15 March, 2022 – “Don’t Let Him Skip”

Associated Press, 17 March, 2022 – “Wisconsin Man Gets Life”

DeForest Times-Tribune, 17 March, 2022 – “Halderson Sentenced to Life Without Parole”

https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/madison.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/8/b7/8b7fc425-ea29-50bb-8d0d-d770a106bdd8/60f0bea8818de.pdf.pdf

https://bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com/madison.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/f/44/f4427ae1-8b51-5327-800f-79ef93141347/612688a6ae1eb.pdf.pdf