The Death of Jada Justice

An article by:
12th May 2021  •  6 min read

On the 16th of June, 2009, 2-year-old Jada Justice vanished. Her cousin claimed she was abducted from outside a convenience store. An investigation, however, would uncover something a lot more sinister.

The Death of Jada Justice

Morbidology Podcast

The article continues below

Morbidology is a weekly true crime podcast created and hosted by Emily G. Thompson. Using investigative research combined with primary audio, Morbidology takes an in-depth look at true crime cases from all across the world.

On the 16th of June, 2009, 2-year-old Jada Justice was reported missing by her 18-year-old cousin, Engelica Castillo, who had been babysitting the toddler. She claimed to investigators that she had left Jada in the car outside Glen Park Ridge Road in Lake County, Indiana, as she went into the gas station’s convenience store to purchase some milk. She said that when she went back out to the car, Jada was gone.1 Jada lived in Portage with her mother, Melissa Swointek, and her two brothers. She had been staying with Engelica because Melissa had plans to go out of town with her boyfriend.

Jada’s uncle, Mike Valdez, immediately sought the help of the community in searching for Jada. Missing person fliers were printed and distributed throughout the area. They described Jada as an African American toddler standing at 2 feet 2 inches tall, weighing around 35 pounds. She was last seen wearing an orange skirt and striped shirt. Since there was no evidence that an abduction had taken place, an Amber Alert could not be issued.

Jada’s cousin, Engelica, was taken into custody as a person of interest and it was announced that she may be charged with neglect. According to family members and investigators, they were suspicious of Engelica’s version of events. Furthermore, when Engelica was brought in for questioning, she was evidently under the influence of drugs. She had attempted to hit one of the investigators and had ominously said: “God is taking care of Jada. God is watching over her.”

“Why are you going to park on one side of the building while it’s raining outside, pouring rain, if you got to go in the store and get some milk? Why wouldn’t you park in the front and run in and grab the milk? Why would you leave the doors unlocked so somebody could grab a child out of the car?” questioned Jada’s father, Clarence Justice. Mike also questioned why Engelica would take Jada with her to run errands instead of leaving her with her boyfriend and couldn’t understand why she had driven past several other convenience stores before stopping at the one in Gary. Moreover, it would be revealed that sniffer dogs did not pick up Jada’s scent at the scene, including in the car.2

On the 24th of June, 11 days after Jada vanished, her body was discovered encased in concrete in a swampy area in rural Westville. She had multiple skull fractures and her death was ruled a homicide. It was announced that in addition to Engelica, her boyfriend, Tim Tkachik, was also arrested. Both of them were charged with the murder of Jada as well as neglect of a dependent, battery and false informing.

According to the affidavit, Tim had told investigators that he had awoken on the 13th of June to find Engelica pulling Jada’s hair and hitting her. The night before, they had taken heroin. He said that Jada was not crying so Engelica hit her even harder. He further said that Engelica then hit Jada with such force that she fell and hit her head on the table. She then ordered Jada to stand in a corner but when Jada cried, Engelica started hitting her in the head with closed fists.3

Later on, they noticed that Jada wasn’t breathing when they drove to buy more heroin. Tim allegedly said to Engelica: “I told you to stop. I told you enough is enough.” Tim claimed that they had tried to perform CPR on Jada but to no avail.4

They drove back home with the body of Jada and then decided that they needed to get rid of her. Tim confessed to putting Jada’s body in garbage bags and taking her to a wooded area in LaPorte County. Here, he attempted to burn Jada’s body to ashes. However, the fire caused an explosion which burned him on the face and required medical treatment.  When this attempt was unsuccessful, Tim and Engelica placed Jada’s body into a tub filled with concrete. When the concrete dried, they drove Jada to a rural area near Westville and threw her into a swamp. As a matter of fact, it had been Tim who led investigators to Jada’s body.

Both Tim and Engelica would plead not guilty to all of the charges and they were ordered to stand trial.

In early July, Jada was led to rest. Around 300 people packed into the Calvary Tabernacle Church of Griffith to pay their final respects to the little girl. Her father, Clarence, said that his daughter had provided two years of nothing but love, adding: “She gave me the strength to start loving again.” Her mother, Melissa, said: “I’m glad a lot of people came and showed support.”5

A couple of days later, Clarence would seek custody of his two sons who were under the care of Melissa. He said he felt as though he and his wife could provide a safe environment for his two sons. “I just feel my boys are safer in my arms than with anybody else,” he said.6 He would be awarded custody.

In fact, Melissa would later be charged with neglect of a dependent resulting in death. According to prosecutors, Melissa had put her daughter in a situation that had resulted in her death. Back in summer of 2006, Tim was dealing cocaine and marijuana when he started dating Engelica. Then around Christmas time, Engelica introduced Tim to her family, including Melissa. The couple later moved in with Melissa and she knew that they were both dealing drugs. She told them not to keep large quantities of drugs inside her home but accepted marijuana from them for her own personal use. She also left Jada and her young son in their care frequently.

When the couple moved out, Melissa continued to leave her children in their care despite the fact she knew that they were drug dealers. In fact, she often left her children with them for long periods of time and wouldn’t arrive to pick them up at the arranged time.7 Tim was making thousands of dollars a week selling marijuana, cocaine and prescription pills. The couple often took heroin together but didn’t sell it.

Tim would ultimately strike a plea deal with prosecutors to avoid a death sentence in return for his testimony against Engelica. During her murder trial, he would reveal that Engelica had beaten Jada to death after she dumped a drink mix and spilled a container of syrup. He admitted that he had held Jada down while Engelica repeatedly hit her with a belt. He also revealed that he often took Jada along to drug deals when she was in their “care.” He claimed that he hadn’t abused Jada, other than the day of her death, but said that Englica “would go crazy.”8

Engelica’s defence lawyer, however, would try and place the blame directly on Tim. He depicted Tim as so impatient with Jada that he threw her into the bathtub at least twice during her stay with the couple. He also mentioned the couple’s heavy drug use, and claimed that there was no intent so there was no murder.9

During closing arguments, Prosecutor David Urbanki said to the jury that when Engelica was first arrested, she was secretly recorded telling Tim to claim it was an accident: “They can’t prove we did that,” she said. The jury would only deliberate for around two hours before finding Engelica guilty of Jada’s murder.

Tim Tkachik would be sentenced to 40 years for his role in the murder while Engelica Castillo would be sentenced to a minimum of 65 years in prison. The charges of neglect against Melissa Swiontek would be dismissed.10

4.3 10 votes
Article Rating


  1. The Times, 17 June, 2009 – “Police Search for Missing Toddler”
  2. Associated Press, 18 June, 2009 – “Family Suspicious About How Ind. Toddler Vanished”
  3. News & Politics Examiner, 28 June, 2012 – “Babysitter’s Boyfriend Led Police to Jada Justice’s Body”
  4. Associated Press, 26 June, 2009 – “2 Charged in Death of Missing Ind. Toddler”
  5. News & Politics Examiner, 4 July, 2009 – “Indiana Toddler Jada Justice Laid to Rest”
  6. News & Politics Examiner, 14 July, 2009 – “Dad of Murdered 2 Year Old Jada Seeks Custody”
  7. The Post-Tribune, 23 July, 2011 – “Mother of Jada Justice Charged with Neglect”
  8. The Times, 25 June, 2013 – “Tkachik Takes the Stand in Case Against Mom of Jada Justice”
  9. The Times, 5 August, 2010 – “Several Testify as Jada Justice Case Begins”
  10. The Times, 19 July, 2013 – “Judge Gives Man Who Helped Kill Jada Justice 40 Years”


Notify me of

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
3 years ago

Charges against the mother should not have been dismissed. I’m thrilled dad got custody though. We see too many fathers being denied custody of their children when the mothers are clearly not in the right place or state of mind to raise a child.

Weed is one thing, and that’s worthy of debate, but knowingly leaving your 2-year-old with people who do hard drugs is just insane.

3 years ago
Reply to  Romane

it’s not that fathers are denied custody – it’s that they never ask for it. In fact, statistically, when Father’s ask for custody they get it 65% of the time. The truth is most Father’s are more than happy to hand over full custody and only see their kids at weekends. Thousands upon thousands don’t even bother paying child support.
Also, men statistically more often sexually snd physically abuse children. Maybe you should worry more about those issues than these made up silly gripes you have and haven’t even bothered to google?

Alyssa (Jada's aunt)
Alyssa (Jada's aunt)
2 years ago
Reply to  Romane

The judge said it shouldn’t have even made it to court. That the charges were laughable. She didn’t know they were dealing or doing drugs (besides weed). Engelica had been babysitting for Melissa for literal years with no problems. The kids loved her to the point that Jada was packing her own bag to go.

Oh, and the reason Jada was even being babysat is because CJ said it “wasn’t his week” so he wouldn’t watch her. He’s not a good person.

M t
M t
1 year ago
Reply to  Romane

I have used meth for almost 10 years and have no intention of quitting anytime soon. I have been married for 16 years and have a 15 year old. I also work for a very well known corporation, making very good money, no felonies, own a house and two cars, etc. In other words, take your presumptions and stick them where the sun doesn’t shine.

None Ya
None Ya
3 years ago

Mother should have been tried and convicted, also, and not just of neglect! She should be in prison, too!!!

Nothanks you
Nothanks you
1 year ago

Weird that nothing about Melissa mentions that she is the parent of TWO dead babies. She had a ypung wheelchair bound son die in her home before Jada died

1 year ago

RIP baby girl

You may also like:

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x